1dot.ai Logo1dot.ai
October 2026 · Finder Replacements Tested

XtraFinder Doesn't Really Work on macOS 26: Best Alternatives

Both XtraFinder and TotalFinder need System Integrity Protection weakened to run at all, and neither developer officially claims macOS 26 Tahoe support. Here is what actually still works, what Apple already copied, and five alternatives worth your time.

By Gowtham V · Founder & Lead Developer, 1dot.ai

5 alternatives compared·Updated October 20, 2026·11 min read
Quick picks: Path Finder if you want the most complete, actively updated Finder replacement and don't mind a subscription. ForkLift if you also move files to cloud storage or a server often, as a one-time license. Commander One for the cheapest full-featured one-time dual-pane option. Marta if you want free and open source and can live with a smaller team behind it. Quick X Folder Preview if what you actually miss is being able to peek inside a folder or archive without opening it, not dual-pane browsing itself.

Disclosure: Quick X Folder Preview is made by 1dot.ai, the publisher of this article. It is not a Finder replacement and we say so plainly below, since it solves a narrower problem than XtraFinder ever did. Every version number, price, and macOS requirement below was checked directly against each vendor's own site on October 20, 2026, except where a source is otherwise noted.

XtraFinder and TotalFinder both added things to the Mac Finder years before Apple did: a second pane for browsing two folders at once, tabs, and an "Open Terminal Here" menu item. For a long stretch of the 2010s they were close to essential for anyone who managed files for a living. The catch was always how they worked: both inject code directly into Finder.app while it is running, the same trick SIMBL plugins used before Apple shut that door.

That door has been closing for a decade. System Integrity Protection arrived in OS X El Capitan in 2015 specifically to stop this kind of injection into protected processes, and every macOS release since has added more around it, Library Validation, a fully read-only signed system volume, and tighter notarization checks. Neither XtraFinder nor TotalFinder has an official answer for macOS 26 Tahoe. Here is exactly what that means in practice, and what to use instead.

What's In This Guide
  1. Why XtraFinder and TotalFinder Don't Really Work Anymore
  2. What Apple Already Copied From Them
  3. 1. Path Finder: Most Complete Replacement
  4. 2. ForkLift: Best for Cloud and Server Transfers
  5. 3. Commander One: Cheapest Full-Featured Option
  6. 4. Marta: Free and Open Source
  7. 5. Quick X Folder Preview: If It's Just Previews You Miss
  8. Full Comparison Table
  9. FAQ

Why XtraFinder and TotalFinder Don't Really Work Anymore

Checked directly against each developer's own site on October 20, 2026:

  • XtraFinder (trankynam.com). Current version is 1.9. The site lists support "For macOS Big Sur Monterey Ventura Sonoma Sequoia," with no mention of Tahoe anywhere on the page, and its footer copyright still reads 2023. Its own FAQ only documents the System Integrity Protection steps needed through OS X 10.11–10.15 and Big Sur, nothing newer. One recent report on a Mac enthusiast forum described it running without crashing on a Tahoe Mac, just visually unrefreshed for the new interface, but that is a single user's anecdote, not a developer claim.
  • TotalFinder (binaryage.com). Current version is 1.15.1, and the download page states official support for "macOS 13, 12, 11, and 10.15" only, nothing past Ventura. The same page says "SIP must remain weakened while using TotalFinder" and that "Apple Silicon compatibility must be manually enabled." On BinaryAge's own community forum, Tahoe reports through late 2025 are mixed: it kept working for several people who upgraded an existing Mac in place, almost always with a broken preferences pane, while clean installs on Apple Silicon failed outright because the code injection it depends on could not attach. One Intel clean install worked, after fully disabling SIP in Recovery and manually granting Library permissions by hand.

Neither app is dead in the sense of refusing to launch. They are dead in the sense that matters more: no developer claims to support the OS you are probably running, the install path still asks you to weaken a system security feature, and the result is unreliable enough that several 2025 forum reports describe it failing on a clean install of the exact same macOS version that worked fine for someone else who upgraded in place.

A Note on Pricing
TotalFinder's own licensing page still describes a 14-day trial after which "you have to buy it or uninstall it," with no price listed on the page we checked. A third-party tracker, AlternativeTo, claims it was discontinued and made free back in 2021. We could not resolve which is current, so treat any price you see quoted elsewhere as unconfirmed until BinaryAge's own store page says otherwise.

What Apple Already Copied From Them

Before you go looking for a replacement, it is worth knowing how much of the original reason to install XtraFinder has quietly disappeared, because Apple built it into Finder directly:

  • Tabs. Native since OS X Yosemite in 2014. Cmd+T opens a new one in the same window.
  • Keep folders on top. A native Finder Settings option since macOS Sierra in 2016, though it only applies when a window is sorted by name specifically.
  • Color tags. Right-click any item and assign one, no plugin required.
  • A visible path bar. View > Show Path Bar, native for years now.
  • Moving instead of copying. Cmd+C to copy, then Option+Cmd+V to paste as a move rather than a duplicate. There is still no literal Cut shortcut, but the result is the same file ending up in one place instead of two.

What is still missing from stock Finder, and the actual reason to look at a replacement at all, is a genuine second pane inside one window for browsing two locations side by side, plus the deeper batch-rename, archive, and remote-connection tools the four apps below build around that layout.

1. Path Finder: Most Complete Replacement

1

Path Finder

Two decades of development, now on a subscription model

Path Finder has been a standalone Finder replacement since long before XtraFinder existed, with dual-pane browsing, tabs, a built-in Terminal pane, a drop stack for staging files mid-move, and a module system for extras like a hex viewer and a disk-space analyzer. None of it needs SIP touched, since it is a normal app, not something living inside Finder.app.

As of this check (October 20, 2026), the current release is Path Finder 26, a jump from version 11 as the developer renumbered to match the calendar year, requiring macOS 10.13 or later. Pricing moved to an auto-renewing annual subscription at $29.95 a year, with standalone, non-renewing licenses also available at $32.95 for one year, $55.95 for two years, or $122.95 for five years, none of which are a true lifetime purchase. There is a 30-day trial per the developer's own terms of service.

The trade-off next to XtraFinder specifically is scope creep in the other direction: Path Finder is a much bigger, more opinionated app with its own learning curve, not a light layer added to the Finder you already know.

Most feature-complete$29.95/yr or $32.95-$122.95 fixed termsmacOS 10.13+30-day trial
Strengths
  • True dual-pane browsing in one window
  • Built-in Terminal pane, drop stack, modules
  • Actively updated, no SIP changes needed
  • Longest track record of this group
Limitations
  • No true one-time, perpetual license option
  • Biggest learning curve of the four replacements
  • Mac only

2. ForkLift: Best for Cloud and Server Transfers

2

ForkLift

Dual-pane file manager built around moving files, not just browsing them

ForkLift defaults to a dual-pane layout and adds built-in connections to FTP, SFTP, WebDAV, Amazon S3, and other cloud storage alongside your local drives, so dragging a file from a local folder into a remote one works the same way it would between two local panes. It also bundles a Finder sync-folder tool and a batch-rename utility.

As of this check (October 20, 2026), the current release is 4.7.6, released September 29, 2026, requiring macOS 14.6 Sonoma or later, the steepest minimum OS requirement of the four replacements here. Pricing, confirmed on BinaryNights' own store page, is a one-time single-user license at $19.95 with one year of updates included, or $34.95 for two years of updates, and a family license covering multiple people in one household at $29.95 for one year of updates or $49.95 for two years. Every tier is a lifetime license for the version it covers. Buying further updates later requires a new license, not a subscription renewal.

The macOS 14.6 floor rules it out immediately if you are still on Ventura or an older Sonoma point release, which several XtraFinder holdouts specifically are, since they tend to be the same users avoiding frequent OS upgrades.

$19.95 one-time (1 Mac)Built-in cloud/server connectionsmacOS 14.6+ requiredFree trial available
Strengths
  • Cheapest true one-time license here
  • Native FTP/SFTP/S3/WebDAV panes
  • Actively shipping, recent release
  • Family license covers multiple users
Limitations
  • Requires macOS 14.6 or later, the highest floor here
  • Further updates need a new license eventually
  • Mac only

3. Commander One: Cheapest Full-Featured Option

3

Commander One

A free dual-pane base, with the deeper features behind one cheap unlock

Commander One ships a free tier with dual-pane browsing, ZIP compression, a hex and binary file viewer, and root-level file system access already included. The paid PRO Pack adds cloud storage connections, a built-in terminal emulator, and support for mounting remote drives and devices directly into its panes.

As of this check (October 20, 2026), the current release is 3.18, build 4006, released September 25, 2026, requiring macOS 10.13 or later, the most forgiving minimum OS of the four. The PRO Pack is a one-time $29.99 for a single Mac, or about $99.99 covering five Macs, per our own separately verified Files Magic AI vs. Commander One comparison.

Of the four full replacements here, it asks the least of your Mac and your wallet if all you need is dual-pane browsing with occasional archive or remote work, rather than Path Finder's full module system or ForkLift's deeper cloud integration.

Free tier includes dual-panePRO Pack $29.99 one-timemacOS 10.13+Lowest minimum OS of the four
Strengths
  • Genuinely useful free tier, not just a demo
  • Cheapest paid unlock of the four replacements
  • Runs back to macOS 10.13
  • Recently updated (September 2026)
Limitations
  • Terminal and cloud panes are PRO-only
  • Less module depth than Path Finder
  • Mac only

4. Marta: Free and Open Source

4

Marta

A lean, native two-panel manager with no price and a small team

Marta is a free, open-source, native Swift app built around a two-panel layout with its own window and tab support, maintained by a single developer and supported through Patreon rather than license sales. It has no connection to Finder.app at all, so it needs no SIP changes and carries none of the injection risk XtraFinder and TotalFinder do.

As of this check (October 20, 2026), the current public version is 0.8.2. Its own site states no explicit minimum macOS version, and its footer still reads "© Yan Zhulanow, 2016–2024," with its most recent blog post titled "Marta 0.8.2: Back on track!," which on its own suggests a maintenance gap before that release rather than a steady cadence. Worth testing on your own Mac before you rely on it daily, given how small the team behind it is.

If free and auditable matters more to you than a guaranteed update schedule, it is the one alternative here with no price tag and no vendor to eventually stop paying.

Free, open sourceNo SIP changes, not a Finder pluginSmall team, uneven release cadenceNo stated minimum macOS
Strengths
  • Completely free, open source and auditable
  • Native Swift app, no Finder injection
  • Two-panel layout plus tabs
Limitations
  • One-person project, release gaps have happened
  • No stated minimum macOS version to check against
  • No commercial support if something breaks

5. Quick X Folder Preview: If It's Just Previews You Miss

5

Quick X Folder Preview

Not a Finder replacement. A narrower fix for a narrower complaint.

We make this one, so read this section as the vendor talking. Quick X Folder Preview adds Quick Look extensions to stock Finder: press Space on a folder, a ZIP or RAR archive, source code, Markdown, or an ebook or comic file, and it shows you what is inside without opening it or extracting anything. It has no second pane, no tabs, and does not change how Finder windows work in any way.

Some people who still search for XtraFinder are not actually missing dual-pane browsing. They are missing the ability to glance inside a messy Downloads folder or a client's ZIP file without a detour through opening it first, a narrower, more specific complaint. As of this check, it runs on macOS 13.0 Ventura or later, on Apple silicon or Intel, is signed and notarized by Apple with no SIP changes involved anywhere, and costs $4.99 once after a 14-day free trial.

Be clear with yourself about which problem you actually have before buying anything here. If you want a second pane, tabs, or a built-in terminal, this does not do any of that, and you should pick one of the four replacements above instead.

$4.99 one-timeNo SIP changes, sandboxedNo dual-pane, no tabsmacOS 13.0+
Strengths
  • Cheapest option here by a wide margin
  • Sandboxed, signed, notarized, no security trade-off
  • Solves "peek inside without opening" directly
Limitations
  • Does not replace Finder's browsing at all
  • No dual-pane, no tabs, no terminal pane
  • Wrong pick if dual-pane is what you actually miss

Full Comparison Table

ToolDual-Pane / TabsSIP Changes NeededMin. macOSPrice
XtraFinder (for reference)✓ Both✗ Yes, historically requiredUnlisted (site covers through Sequoia only)Free
TotalFinder (for reference)✓ Both✗ Must "remain weakened"13, 12, 11, 10.15 only (official)Unconfirmed, see note above
Path Finder✓ Both✓ None10.13+$29.95/yr or $32.95–$122.95 fixed term
ForkLift✓ Both✓ None14.6+$19.95 one-time (1 Mac)
Commander One✓ Dual-pane (free tier)✓ None10.13+Free, or $29.99 PRO one-time
Marta✓ Both✓ NoneUnlistedFree, open source
Quick X Folder Preview✗ Neither✓ None13.0+$4.99 one-time

Every row above was checked directly against the vendor's own site on October 20, 2026, except TotalFinder's price, which could not be confirmed (see the pricing note earlier in this guide).

Which One Should You Actually Pick?

  • You want the closest thing to "everything XtraFinder did, and more," actively maintained. Path Finder, if the subscription doesn't bother you.
  • You regularly move files to cloud storage, FTP, or a server. ForkLift, as a true one-time purchase, as long as you're already on macOS 14.6 or later.
  • You want dual-pane browsing without spending much, and don't need deep cloud integration. Commander One's free tier, with the $29.99 PRO Pack if you later want its terminal or remote-mount features.
  • You want free and open source, and don't mind a smaller team behind it. Marta.
  • Your actual complaint is "I can't see what's inside this folder or ZIP without opening it," not dual-pane browsing. Quick X Folder Preview, at a tenth of the price of the others, because it is solving a different, smaller problem.
When Sticking With XtraFinder or TotalFinder Still Makes Sense
If you upgraded an existing Mac in place rather than doing a clean install, already have one of these configured exactly how you like it, and are not planning to reinstall macOS from scratch any time soon, ripping it out for a new tool solves a problem you don't currently have. The honest trade-off is that System Integrity Protection stays weakened system-wide for as long as you keep it installed, a real and ongoing security cost, not a one-time inconvenience. Weigh that against how disruptive relearning a new file manager would actually be for you, rather than assuming either choice is automatically right.

Whichever direction you go, back up first. If you are moving off an injection-based plugin, a clean uninstall followed by a fresh install of whichever replacement you pick is less error-prone than trying to run both at once.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does XtraFinder work on macOS 26 Tahoe?
Unofficially, for some people. XtraFinder’s own site (trankynam.com) lists support through Big Sur, Monterey, Ventura, Sonoma, and Sequoia, but says nothing about Tahoe, and its copyright footer still reads 2023. One recent Mac forum report described it running without crashing on Tahoe, just without a visual refresh for the new design. That is one user’s experience, not a developer statement, and the install still requires disabling System Integrity Protection, a real security trade-off the developer’s own documentation only walks through up to Big Sur.
Does TotalFinder work on macOS 26 Tahoe?
Inconsistently. BinaryAge’s own download page for TotalFinder 1.15.1 lists official support for “macOS 13, 12, 11, and 10.15” only, nothing newer. On BinaryAge’s own community forum, several Tahoe reports through late 2025 describe it working after an in-place upgrade from an older macOS version, with the preferences pane broken in most cases, while clean installs on Apple Silicon Macs failed outright because the Finder code injection TotalFinder relies on could not attach. One Intel clean install succeeded, after fully disabling SIP in Recovery and manually granting Library permissions. None of this is an official BinaryAge claim of support.
Why do XtraFinder and TotalFinder need System Integrity Protection disabled?
Both work by injecting their own code into Finder.app while it runs, the same technique SIMBL-based plugins used before Apple locked it down. System Integrity Protection, introduced in OS X El Capitan in 2015, blocks exactly that kind of code injection into protected system processes, so both tools have required SIP to be at least partly disabled since then. Apple has only tightened the surrounding protections since, including Library Validation and a fully read-only system volume, which is why TotalFinder’s own site says SIP “must remain weakened” for as long as you use it, not just during installation.
What is the closest free alternative to XtraFinder?
Marta. It is a free, open-source, native Swift app with a two-panel layout and its own tabs, and it needs no SIP changes at all because it is a standalone app rather than a Finder plugin. The trade-off is a much smaller team behind it: its public changelog shows a multi-year gap before a “back on track” release, and its site states no minimum macOS version, so test it on your exact setup before relying on it.
Can I get dual-pane Finder windows without installing anything?
Not really, no. Stock Finder has absorbed several things XtraFinder made popular, tabs since OS X Yosemite in 2014, a “Keep folders on top” view option since macOS Sierra in 2016 (it only applies when you are sorting by name), color tags, and a visible path bar. A genuine second pane showing a different folder in the same window is not one of them. For that you need a standalone replacement like Path Finder, ForkLift, Commander One, or Marta.
Does Quick X Folder Preview replace XtraFinder?
No, and we would be overselling our own product to say otherwise. Quick X Folder Preview adds Quick Look extensions, so pressing Space on a folder, archive, or code file shows you what is inside without opening it. It has no dual-pane view, no tabs, and does not touch Finder’s browsing behavior at all. If dual-pane browsing and tabs are what you actually miss from XtraFinder, get Path Finder, ForkLift, Commander One, or Marta instead. If what you miss is being able to peek inside a folder or a ZIP file without digging through it, that narrower problem is the one we built for.
Is TotalFinder still sold, or is it free now?
Unclear, and that ambiguity is itself worth knowing before you pay anything. A third-party tracker, AlternativeTo, states TotalFinder was discontinued in 2021 and can now be downloaded free. BinaryAge’s own licensing page, however, still describes a 14-day trial after which “you have to buy it or uninstall it,” with no current price listed on the page we checked. Confirm the actual price on BinaryAge’s store before purchasing anything, rather than trusting either source at face value.
Will Apple ever add real dual-pane Finder windows natively?
There is no indication of it. Apple has steadily absorbed individual XtraFinder-era features into Finder over the past decade (tabs, folders-on-top sorting, color tags, the path bar) without ever adding a true second browsing pane inside one window. Given how long that pattern has held, a dedicated dual-pane app remains the only route if you need it, not a feature to wait for.

Checked directly on October 20, 2026, against: XtraFinder's official site, TotalFinder's official site and its licensing page, BinaryAge's community forum thread on macOS Tahoe, Path Finder (Cocoatech) and the TidBITS review of Path Finder 26, ForkLift (BinaryNights) and its store page, Commander One, and Marta. Commander One's PRO Pack price is carried from our separately verified Files Magic AI vs. Commander One comparison.

Want more on what Finder can and can't preview on its own? Read our full guide to previewing files on Mac without opening them, or see what else broke for third-party tools in why Quick Look plugins stopped working on macOS Sequoia and Tahoe.

Just Want to Peek Inside a Folder Without Opening It?

Quick X Folder Preview adds 13 Quick Look extensions to Finder, folders and archives included. No Finder replacement, no SIP changes. Try it free for 14 days.

Try Quick X Folder PreviewRead the Full Preview Guide